How Does McCain’s Healthcare Plan Measure-up?

How Does McCain’s Healthcare Plan Measure-up? – by Catherine Morgan (cross-posted at Care2 Election Blog)

It’s no secret that we are facing a healthcare crisis in this country. I’ve heard quite a bit about the healthcare plans of Barack Obama and Hillary Clinton, but I just realized that I’ve neglected to look at John McCain’s healthcare plan. So, I thought I could use this post to take a closer look at McCain’s plan, and what others are saying about it. I would love to know what you think about too…let me know in comments.

In the above clip, Shawn Tully of Fortune Magazine, begins his interview with CNN by saying that Healthcare (specifically Medicare) is going to bankrupt our country, and that is why the McCain plan is more “fiscally” responsible. Is he kidding? He loses me right there, because as far as I am concerned, the Iraq war is what is going to bankrupt this country (if it hasn’t already). If you don’t believe me, check out this post on military spending…
But to get back to John McCain’s Healthcare plan – here is some of what other bloggers are saying about the McCain Healthcare Plan.This is from An Insider’s View on Health Care…

McCain’s Healthcare Plan is the Worst – Consumer Driven Healthcare Not the Answer

FORTUNE magazine published an opinion piece in their March 17, 2008, issue titled Why McCain has the best health-care plan. McCain like many of his fellow Republicans believes that giving individuals more responsibility is a way to solve the healthcare crisis.

From The Carpetbagger Report – John McCain and the ‘disaster’ of his healthcare plan…

From time to time, McCain has made encouraging noises on the issue. He’s supported re-importation of medicine from Canada; he’s teamed up with Ted Kennedy on a “patients’ bill of rights”; and he’ll occasionally criticize HMOs and big pharm.

But TNR’s Jonathan Cohn reports today on the healthcare plan McCain unveiled in October, and labels the policy a “disaster.”

. . .

The main point of McCain’s proposal is to change tax policy to make it easier for people to have more insurance options outside their employer.

. . .

No matter which Dem gets the nomination, this is a fight to look forward to. If McCain support for an unpopular war doesn’t undermine his campaign, his useless healthcare policy will.

There were also some interesting comments on this Carpetbagger post. Here is part of one…

There are arguments out there that every US citizen should get access to the same type of healthcare system that federal employees, including all elected federal representative, receive. Until that day occurs, how about making federal elected officials having to live with the same system the rest of have to deal with. Let John McCain see what it’s like to get insurance after three bouts of melanoma along with a spouse who had a stroke and a past issue with drug dependence or to watch his family’s coverage get dropped because the insurance companies feel like it. Maybe then Congress would take some action if they weren’t so insulated from the problem.

Personally, I’m not sold on this plan one bit. As a person with chronic illness and pre-existing conditions, it’s actually a little scary. But that’s just me, what do you think?

Also See:

Lack of Health Insurance is Killing Americans

Brit in a Red State

Grizzly Mama: McCain and Healthcare

Florida Will Not Get To Re-Do Presidential Primary

No Re-Vote For Florida Primary — by Catherine Morgan (cross-posted at Care2 Election Blog)

As a Florida resident and a registered Democrat, I have blogged several times on my annoyance as well as outrage I am feeling over Florida delegates not being counted. My most recent post was – Should Florida and Michigan Have Do-Over Primaries? (there are actually 68 comments ranging from – why people think we should have revote to why they think we should just shut-up and take our punishment for breaking the rules).

I was really holding out hope that the Florida legislator would find a way to at least have a mail-in revote. It seems to me this would have been the best solution, but it apparently doesn’t seem that way to the Florida Democratic Party officials.Hillary Clinton continues to try and keep a plan for two revotes alive.

New York Times – Senator Hillary Rodham Clinton’s hopes of ending the primaries with game-changing victories from new contests in Florida and Michigan grew dim on Tuesday as Florida officially scuttled plans for a new vote and Michigan lawmakers appeared far from a deal.

In a sign of how badly she thinks she needs the Michigan delegates to catch the Democratic front-runner, Senator Barack Obama, Mrs. Clinton made a last-minute schedule change and planned to fly to Detroit on Wednesday to plead with Michigan lawmakers to approve a new primary election in June to replace the January contest that awarded no delegates.

“We will go and make the case for a revote,” said Mo Elleithee, a spokesman for Mrs. Clinton.

Mr. Obama’s campaign has resisted a new contest, saying that Michigan Democrats are divided, that a revote would not make much difference in the overall delegate count and that the Clinton camp was trying to change the rules to suit itself.

I’m happy to see that Hillary Clinton is willing to stand-up against the DNC and fight for Florida and Michigan voters. I am, however, very disappointed that none of the democratic nominees made any attempt to stand-up for us at the time Howard Dean was making these ridiculous punishments. I think if one or all of them had stood up to Howard Dean and refused to allow him to disenfranchise Florida or Michigan voters, things would be a lot different right now. But instead, they all went along with him…more like followers than leaders. Instead we just have Barack who doesn’t care at all about us, and Hillary who only cares because she needs our delegates. That’s not going to play so well in the general election.

In my opinion, if Hillary wins the Democratic nomination there is a chance that Florida could go blue in November. Floridians obviously like her, and they do see her as someone at least trying to help the people of Florida. Even though she was a little late to the party, she is at least here now. But you can’t say the same for Barack Obama. It’s my opinion that many Florida voters are disappointed in him for his lack of concern over whether or not our votes count, and that’s a pretty big deal. For that reason, I believe that if Barack Obama is the Democratic Nominee, Florida will most likely be red in November. Although, if he unites with Hillary and begins to fight for the voting rights of Michigan and Florida, this could turn the tables for him.