Informed Voters

Dedicated to inform and educate the voting public through articles, ideas, and links.

Michael Moore’s new movie “Sicko” – What it says about the current state of our healthcare system, and what can be done to fix it.

Posted by Catherine Morgan on June 15, 2007

Michael Moore on NightLine…

More on Michael Moore at — michaelmoore.com

Watch this story about how an RN of 30 years is dropped from her health insurance just before being diagnosed with two stage four cancer.

American healthcare is being bled dry by for-profit insurance corporations, who waste hundreds of billions of care dollars each year on bureaucracy, markets, profits, and political contributions. No other developed country in the world makes this mistake—and no other country spends so much for so little. We can Guarantee Healthcare for all Americans by replacing these heartless insurance monsters with a national, non-profit risk pool dedicated to providing every American with the care they need. How does it work?

—————————————————

Joseph A. Palermo: California Nurses and Michael Moore Make History

It was a truly historic day in Sacramento this afternoon when over ten thousand nurses from all over the country rallied with filmmaker Michael Moore in front of the Capitol building. The California Nurses Association, along with the State Senator Sheila Kuehl, packed into a hearing room to listen to Michael Moore and three people featured in his new movie, Sicko, testify about the appalling state of America’s broken for profit health care system. — read more from The Huffington Post

Thousands of nurses and health care professionals, along with people from other unions, (such as myself from the California Faculty Association), gathered outside and watched Moore’s testimony on five giant TVs inside huge tents. We rallied in the hot sun, waving little fans and placards the nurses handed out. Then we all marched down to the historic art deco Crest Theater downtown for a special pre-release viewing of Sicko.

The goal of Sicko, as Moore told both the Senate committee and the rally outside, is to provide an organizing tool to get people so angry they will rise up to demand common-sense solutions to the health care crisis. The current greed-driven system where huge corporations pursue lavish profits at the public’s expense has created a human catastrophe. — read more from The Huffington Post

Moore wants his fellow Americans to seize this moment when health care will be publicized to demand that the state governments and Congress enact a universal, single-payer system similar to what exists in Canada, France, and England (countries he visits in the movie). Moore says we should demand that our government regulate the pharmaceutical companies “just like a public utility.”

Go to GuaranteedHealthcare.org or to the California Nurses Association website for suggestions about taking action. The first step will be to press for passage of Sheila Kuehl’s health care bill here in California. Moore pointed out that California has been in the lead on many issues, including raising the minimum wage, and we have an opportunity to lead the nation out of the dark ages on health care. — read more from The Huffington Post

————————————————————-

Also See: The Growing Health Care Crisis and the Uninsured in America

————————————————————–

More from The Huffington Post

I know I must sound like an awful snob; as if I view the biggest question about universal health care to be the question of allowing the well-off to opt out and leave bare-bones public care to the no-choice masses. Then again, in a way, that is the biggest question. Reprehensible as the U.S. system is, it remains true that there are many more Americans who are insured than who are not. Thus, if, in approaching health-care reform, we don’t think about the have’s as well as the have not’s, we may feel very noble — but all we will end up doing is condemning the have-not’s to more of the same. Moreover, in real life, health care is one of those areas where the two groups are not so distinct. Between the totally uninsured and the fabulously well-insured, there are, of course, the precariously insured, the woefully underinsured, the supposedly-insured-but-ultimately-screwed-by-the-insurance-company, and about a hundred other permutations. Likewise, in a sanely-socialized-medicine future, the group that uses the public health system would overlap significantly with the group that doesn’t. Possible opters-out would not only include the rich and spoiled who want to reserve their right to waltz in and order up an MRI for the fun of it — but also far less wealthy people who would mostly avail themselves of the public system, yet would be willing to pay to reserve the right to an alternative should they ever want one. — read full article

comment are pretty interesting too…

———————————————————————-

Another article on the movie…Michael Moore Tackles American Health Care in “Sicko”

———————————————————————-

9 Responses to “Michael Moore’s new movie “Sicko” – What it says about the current state of our healthcare system, and what can be done to fix it.”

  1. mirth said

    As always, Catherine, well thought out and presented information. I’m making my way through the links you provide. I haven’t seen Sicko, but I will soon.

  2. Hi Mirth — As always, it’s nice getting comments from you.

  3. jesse said

    Usually I cringe whenever I hear Moore’s big mouth, but for once I have to agree with him! Our healhcare system SUCKS! We pay over $1000.00 a month for health insurance (no dental or eye care coverage), and still whenever a doctor sugests a test for something, our insurance co. refuses coverage. The stupid company will not even cover allergy meds for our youngest, they think he does not need them! Also, we have yet to find a doctor who is good WITH decent “bed side manners”. Lately, you can only find doctors who are business only, you only have to go to the office to find that it is more like a visit to any other company out there, cold, uncaring, and worried about getting thier money only. They are deffinately NOT concerned about thier patients!

  4. Hi Jesse — I agree with you 100%. I also think this problem is going to continue to get much worse before it gets better. Any attempt to fix this problem by the government will have to include cooperation with the insurance and drug industries (because they give so much money to elected officials). This will continue to be a “debate” and a nice “wedge issue” for the politicians…but I don’t see an actual solution any time soon. The only people that would benefit from a solution are the American people…most decisions (if not all) made by our government are to benefit multi-million (billion) dollar industries…not the American people.

    I hope I am wrong.

  5. bear with – wet nails – minimal punctuation.

    i worked in health care for two decades – lots of public health. i know how bad it is – i have seen it from the bottom up – because i was fucking exhausted and looking up from the floor of the trauma bay. [how's that for a metaphor?] it is so effed up i don’t know where to even start. i just know that if omeone started from scratch to build a healthcare system, this wouldn’t be it.

    [btw - i'm all about the quid pro quo - you are a partner in thought crime on my blogroll.]

  6. Thanks for the comment “Blue Girl”…you are part of my blogroll as well.

  7. D-day said

    Wow CM! Great post……again!
    I’m looking forward to seeing Sicko. As someone who no longer has insurance and will be in big trouble if I ever get it again because of “pre-existing conditions”, this issue is important to me. Thanks for this.

  8. Love&Peace&Knowledge*Girl said

    I know Michael Moore may not be the most popular director out there, but this film is so moving, factual, and shocking that I have found so much respect for Moore. In my opinion, this picture transformed Moore’s status from a controversial documentary director to what the magazine Empire described as an, “auteur.” Sicko is truly Moore’s magnum opus.

    Sicko honestly depicted the disturbing reality of the American healthcare “system” with a diverse selection of interviewees whose testimonies are all in-depth, genuine, and had evidence to support their statements.

    Also the police officers’ side story was really touching, as were the other stories. Moore also showed a generous side in this film (if I say anymore about it, I’ll spoil a touching part in the movie). Even if it was to gain support for this film, by doing what he did, he saved an ailing woman’s life.

    Although I don’t have a complete understanding of the Canadian, French, British, or Cuban healthcare systems, and I’m also aware that they are not perfect. However, it’s made evident in Sicko that they are far superior to their US counterpart. The United States is presently the only nation among “first-world” countries that doesn’t have a UNIVERSAL HEALTHCARE SYSTEM. Even South Africa has a universal healthcare system. (South Africa is a country where it’s too dangerous for its citizens to work in its cities at nighttime!) Whether you view my option of our healthcare system as cynicism or as reasonable objection, you can attribute it to Sicko.

    Sicko is one reason why I LOVE documentaries, they force you to look at the world right under your nose or out of the lens of the CNN, Fox, or MSNBC cameras.

  9. Love&Peace*Girl said

    Sorry, I phrased a passage in my writing wrong. I meant was that I liked that Cuba had a universal healthcare system, it still isn’t great. However, I meant what I said about the Canadian, French, and British healthcare systems.

Leave a Reply

XHTML: You can use these tags: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <pre> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong>